Showing posts with label Josef von Sternberg. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Josef von Sternberg. Show all posts

Thursday, January 8, 2009

“The Scarlet Empress” and “The First Christmas”

“The Scarlet Empress,” Josef von Sternberg’s surreal mediation on the rise of Catherine the Great of Russia, was a box-office flop when it opened in 1934. Even the seductive charms of Marlene Dietrich as Catherine could not endear this exercise in realpolitik to American audiences who wanted, at least at the movies, that good should triumph over evil and that love be without self-interest. “The Scarlet Empress” instead shows Catherine fully realizing that to avoid being killed by her crazy husband, the Grand Duke Peter (Sam Jaffe), she must give up on love and use the only weapon she has: sex. Her shedding of her humanity is chillingly portrayed in the banquet scene, in which the Archimandrite Simeon Tevedovsky (Davidson Clark), one of the few clergy at court sympathetic to Catherine, conducts the ritualistic alms collection for the poor. Of course, begging for charity is an inadequate substitute for standing up for justice for the poor, but such thoughts are far from the minds of the court clergy, who clearly relish their positions and are content to be subservient to the royal power. As the alms bowl is passed, Catherine puts in much of her jewelry, while Peter’s mistress (Ruthelma Stevens) contemptuously throws in a crust of bread. Peter shows his scorn by slapping the Archimandrite in the face. With that, we see a change in Catherine. Catching the eye of her current lover, the young officer Orloff (Gavin Gordon), who was standing behind her chair, she viciously knots a scarf. Orloff understands his mission, and after the banquet, we see him strangling Peter, thus ensuring the throne for Catherine. As Robin Wood writes in the notes for the 2001 Criterion Collection edition, which we saw, such a perversion of reciprocal love into sadomasochism within a culture built upon power relations is one of the recurrent themes of the films von Sternberg made with Dietrich.
The scene and indeed the movie itself also illustrate the theme that Marcus Borg and John Dominic Crossan develop in “The First Christmas,” their groundbreaking book. They write that following Jesus is a political decision, an alternative to following Caesar. Christian disciples are called on to be committed to peace through justice, in contrast to peace through victory, the way of the Caesars of the world.
Victory, of course, is won through violence: war; injustice; and, in Catherine’s case; murder. In contrast, justice almost always requires nonviolent resistance to unjust power. In the movie, neither the clergy nor Catherine is willing to resist power with nonviolence, because they themselves want power.
The movie climaxes and ends with Catherine’s ecstatic assumption of power. She ruled for more than 34 years and helped open Russia to enlightenment values, but she is remembered more for her victory than for justice. As von Sternberg’s movie emphasizes, She was not a virtuous fairy-tale princess. She was heroic, not sympathetic. This was not a recipe for box office success in 1934 or now, but the movie is a fascinating look at how power corrupts.